1930 Martin 5-17T Tenor Guitar






Update: Per request, I added a second soundclip of this instrument strung lower in GDAE tuning.

I have a soft spot for mahogany-topped Martins. This 5-17T is a fiery little thing and came in pretty close to spec as far as playability was concerned... but did need a fret level/dress, two 3" hairline cracks cleated/filled, a bit of compensation added to the saddle, new pins, and a good setup. After all the adjustments, too, its volume jumped right up and the tone rounded-up with a bit more lower-mids and overall punch. I love how that happens.

I think these earlier, banjo-peg-equipped size 5 tenors are probably the friendliest small-body tenors made. They're easy on the eye and easy on the lap, but were definitely intended for CGDA tuning (or DGBE, for that matter). I'm not a fan of these tuned to octave-mandolin GDAE range as the bass is a bit too tight -- but in the higher, more standard, tunings chords gel into a nice thick bite and lead work sounds smooth and saucy.


The body is 11 1/4" across the lower bout and it has a 22 7/8" scale length. I've currently strung it 30w, 22w, 16, 12 for DGBE tuning. It's all-original save for a new set of ebony bridge pins and endpin.


1 3/16" ebony nut, rosewood headstock veneer, and classy old two-tab geared banjo pegs...


The rosewood board has those cream "micro dots" and the original bar frets -- which were full height and have plenty of height left. My level/dress job was quite light.



The only nod to decoration is the one-ring rosette.


The bridge is good to go and before I set this up I filled/redrilled the pinholes to seat the ball-ends nice and pat. The saddle is now compensated for two-wound/two-plain stringing.


The saddle was its full original height when it got here and remains so. This is what these bridges look like as-original. In old-time and bluegrass circles there's a tendency to want really tall bridges and saddles -- things that most old guitars never had originally.

I consider it mostly a "feel" preference compared to a tonal superiority preference. As far as I'm concerned, the most important element in coaxing power from any pin-bridge guitar is to have decent back-angle behind the saddle so the strings drive the top in a "wave" motion more efficiently.


The satin finish is in really good shape but does have a few places where it's been polished-up from use-wear -- pretty typical.





The Grover two-tab geared pegs (with ivoroid buttons) make tuning much less of a chore vs. standard friction pegs. They hold just fine.









Here's one of the two 3" hairline cracks -- this one was actually quite tight but had some run-out on the top of the wood so it looks wider than it is (it's hard to see it in other pics, no?) -- it's cleated/filled and good to go.


The other one is a tight one on the back that's also cleated.


It comes with a size 5 (or mini-Martin?) Martin gigbag.

Comments

Scott saidā€¦
Absolutely beautiful! Some day I'll own one.
Anonymous saidā€¦
What they said! She's for sale right? What's the distinction again between the 30's and the 50's and 60's? Thanks Jake.
Jake Wildwood saidā€¦
MA: Yup, will be listed a bit later today. There's not much difference "under the hood" v.s. 5-17s and 5-15s, but the tuners change to guitar-style ones by around '38 and over time, to my ears, the bracing seems to be slightly bulked-up to deal with heavier strings. Sonically they're all more-or-less the same. The main difference between 17/15 is that the 15's finish wasn't as glossy and the dot pattern was changed.
Scott saidā€¦
I usually like tenors tuned CGDA, but that sounds really nice in Irish tuning. Thanks for posting!
Oscar Stern saidā€¦
Actually I like the sound of this Guitar in GDAE Tuning cause the body is actually deeper plus I can get a much mellower Jazz Guitar like sound.